GOLDMAN: OPEC's oil production cuts were smart but they're having unintended consequences

The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries made a smart move to limit production, but the move has had some unforeseen effects, according to Goldman Sachs analysts. 

In November, some OPEC members agreed with a few non-members to lower their production levels in a bid to support oil prices. It was the most significant agreement since the oil crash in 2014 as OPEC fought for market share with US shale producers.

The oversupply from the moves for market share pushed the oil market into contango. That's a situation where the price in the futures market is higher than the current spot price, meaning that traders are willing to pay more for oil in the future than now. 

Goldman's Michele Della Vigna said that the inventory build pushed the 2-year forward price of Brent crude, the international benchmark, $5.50 per barrel (or 11%) above the spot price. 

That situation helped US producers at the expense of OPEC. "As OPEC countries sell spot, but US E&Ps [exploration and production companies] sell 50%+ of their production forward, this was giving the E&Ps a competitive advantage," Della Vigna wrote in a note on Tuesday.

"Within one month of the OPEC announcement, the contango declined to US$1.1/bl (2%), achieving the cartel’s purpose. However, the unintended consequence was to underwrite shale activity through a bullish credit market at a time when delayed delivery of the 2011-13 capex boom could lead to record non-OPEC production growth in 2018."

In other words, OPEC's deal started producing the intended effect as oil prices rose. Meanwhile, investors continued to buy energy high-yield bonds to support US producers. 

"Exhibit 3 shows how successful OPEC was in tilting the shape of the Brent forward curve within one month of its announcement," Della Vigna wrote. "However, the unintended shale boom generated by low oil price volatility, a bullish credit market and management confidence is starting to impact the whole curve, shifting it downwards into the incentive price cost of shale production (US$50-55/bl on our estimates)."

And so, OPEC's output cuts could have the unintended effect of hurting their members' economic growth.

"Headline GDP growth in the Gulf looks is likely to slow to an eight-year low of 1.5% in 2017," said Capital Economics' Neil Shearing in a note on Monday. "However, this will be entirely the result of oil production cuts as countries comply with last year’s OPEC deal." 

Goldman included this chart which steps further back to illustrate the headache US shale producers are giving their OPEC counterparts. The efficiency of shale production reduced the oil price US drillers needed to break even, or produce without profit or loss. Low-cost OPEC producers then respond by increasing production where they can.

Shoot

Trending News

Byju’s acquires US-based Osmo for $120 million

Personal care brand Arata Zero Chemicals raises Rs 3.5 crore in seed capital

Etail may lose Rs 40,000 crore, retail to get a 3rd of it

Amazon food biz to log off if new rules remain on menu

Changes to FDI policy unclear, don’t help the cause of startups: Lenskart's Peyush Bansal

Slowdown or not, we are aggressive on US: TCS CEO Rajesh Gopinathan

SpaceX to layoff 10% of workforce

Amazon Pay gets another Rs 300 crore from parent entity

Steadview Capital invests $74M in Ola valuing it at around $6B

Byju’s ups revenue to Rs 490 cr in FY 18, losses drop by half

A Rs 120-cr WhatsApp message to fight fake news

OYO bulks up international leadership with key hires

For Matrix Partners, transaction-based startups mean business

Amazon joins global companies such as Google, WhatsApp and Truecaller that have put their bets on the UPI business in partnership with banks.

Uber looks to double its engineering headcount in India

SoftBank to invest additional $2B in WeWork: Sources

Snapdeal claims to have added 50,000 sellers in last 12 months

Agritech startups Sabziwala and LivLush merge their business under new entity Kamatan

Avail Finance lands $17.2M from Matrix Partners & Ola, Freecharge and Flipkart founders

RBI suggests tax sops, self-regulation to build fintech space

Swiggy hires new CEO for its Access Service, gets new CFO

Logistics company Delhivery registers 44% increase in FY17 revenues

WeWork to acquire one of the oldest social networks, Meetup

Qualcomm rejects Broadcom's $103 billion offer

EasyRewardz gets $2 million Series-A funding

'Anemic' iPhone 8 demand drags Apple shares lower

Lending platform Lenden Club gets Rs 3.5cr in Equity Investment

On festive sales, Flipkart says 65% clients from Tier-II cities